iPhone Lockscreen Battle: LockInfo vs. Cydgets vs. SmartScreen vs. IntelliScreen vs. QuickWidgets

Lockscreen ModsAlright, so here’s the deal. Lately, there have been a burst of various lockscreen mods/apps/hacks/widgets. It’s extremely hard to actually figure out which one someone should actually use. They each have its own design and set of features. Some are free, and some cost money. We won’t go over every feature. We have extensively used each application and have come up with the pros and cons of them. Which one is for you? Continue reading to find out.

Below are the prices for each product:

  1. LockInfo: 14-day trial, then $4.99
  2. SmartScreen: ‘Lite’ version available, $4.99
  3. IntelliScreen: trial, then $9.99
  4. QuickWidgets: free (currently in beta)
  5. Cydget: free

First, let’s start out with LockInfo. Made by David Ashman, the man behind the reflective dock mod, WeatherIcon, and others, you can expect this product to look and feel great; It really does! There are lots of nice add-ons and themes for LockInfo. With LockInfo, you don’t have pages for widgets. It’s all on your main lockscreen in a vertical scrolling manner. You can view weather info, Twitter, Facebook, calendar, mail, and more. At this point, LockInfo is on the top of the chart for our pick of lockscreen mods.

Next up is SmartScreen. Released yesterday, SmartScreen offers multiple pages of widgets as well as easy organization of them. Currently, there are only 4 widgets available, and these widgets are available from the developers of SmartScreen. There are about a dozen other widgets created by third-party developers that they made using the SmartScreen SDK. We emailed a few of these developers, and they all said that they were going to be charging for their widgets. Now, if we remember that the app costs $4.99 (plus tax?), then maybe $1 for each widget, this will bring the total price to over $15, which is a lot for anything mobile related. As for the 4 widgets that are available, they are fairly basic.  Organization of the widgets can be done by tapping and holding on one until it wiggles. SmartScreen can also let you toggle various system  settings like wifi, 3G, bluetooth, and EDGE. Shake to shuffle can also work while the iPod controls are being displayed. At this moment, the lack of widgets make this something that shouldn’t have been released until more widgets were completed. So, at this point, SmartScreen is second.

Third is IntelliScreen. You can use this as a trial, but then you have to pay [a whopping] $10 for the full version. We’ve heard a lot about this and decided to give it a try. Our first impressions were bad, and these were basically lasting impressions. Setting up the widgets was a very unorganized and painful task to complete. After coming up with something that looked half decent, we just weren’t satisfied with anything. At this point, IntelliScreen is third on our list of lockscreen modifications.

Fourth up is QuickWidgets, aka QuickBoard. Currently free and in beta, we really enjoy mod. There are a number of neat widgets, some with hidden and interesting features. Widgets can be organized by tapping on a widget until it wiggles, and letting go. You can then move the widget to other pages. Some widgets have options that you can change right from the lockscreen (denoted by a red dot on the upper-right corner of the widget). What’s different about QuickWidgets is that you can use these widgets to call external actions, like unlocking your device and opening mail, reply to a text message, make a phone call. You can even open the camera by double-tapping on the camera widget. The camera will then do a page peel over the lockscreen. Most of the widgets have multiple sizes, which can be achieved by making the widgets wiggle, then double tapping on one. We would like to see more widgets in the future, such as Twitter and Facebook. If that happened, this would easily be the best jailbroken mode money can buy. At this point, QuickWidgets is second, right under LockInfo.

Last, is Cydget. Cydget is a lockscreen framework that allows people to make widgets for the lockscreen. At the moment, the majority of these ‘widgets’ are very poor and offer very little functionality. Let’s just leave it at that, okay? Cydget is instantly at the bottom of the list.

So, in order of what we like the most, here is the list:

  1. LockInfo
  2. QuickWidgets
  3. SmartScreen
  4. IntelliScreen
  5. Cydget

We really do like LockInfo. There are more and more widgets and themes for it that really expand its functionality and design. QuickWidgets  is also very nice, but we would all like to see more widgets. SmartScreen has had a lot of hype, but didn’t really live up to it. IntelliScreen is just sad, with its high price and with its poor… Everything. We just aren’t going to talk about Cydget anymore.

So! If you’re looking for something to spruce up your lockscreen, take a look at LockInfo and its 2 week free trial. Or, you can try everything else. All is either free or has a trial.

Please let us know what you like the best, either by posting in our forum (link up top), or by commenting on this post.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Thanks for visiting! Be sure to follow us on Twitter: @GumballTech for all the latest news and updates! Also, don't miss the GumballTech YouTube channel for hands on reviews and tutorials!
  • Klondike

    Lockinfo is the shit. Too bad it went paid.

  • Klondike

    Lockinfo is the shit. Too bad it went paid.

  • http://Www.Twitter.com/placeholderzero Dan

    Boy am I glad you posted this… I’ve been trying to find a good lock screen mod for awhile now. Only one I’ve tried out of these is Intelliscreen, and I wasn’t too impressed. I’ve been using LockCalendar, but I’d really like to have more than just calendar info on the lock screen.

    I’m gonna go give LockInfo a try. Thanks for the article!!

  • http://Www.Twitter.com/placeholderzero Dan

    Boy am I glad you posted this… I’ve been trying to find a good lock screen mod for awhile now. Only one I’ve tried out of these is Intelliscreen, and I wasn’t too impressed. I’ve been using LockCalendar, but I’d really like to have more than just calendar info on the lock screen.

    I’m gonna go give LockInfo a try. Thanks for the article!!

  • http://www.jordandev.info/ jordandev

    I switched from Intelliscreen to Lockinfo. Wrote up a short blog post to try and spread the good word.

  • http://www.jordandev.info jordandev

    I switched from Intelliscreen to Lockinfo. Wrote up a short blog post to try and spread the good word.

  • http://goodiphone.com/2009/11/iphone-lockscreen-battle-quickwidgets-vs-lockinfo-vs-cydgets-vs-smartscreen-vs-intelliscreen/ iPhone Lockscreen Battle: QuickWidgets vs. LockInfo vs. Cydgets vs. SmartScreen vs. IntelliScreen – GooDiPhone

    [...] This article was made by brian and posted on gumballtech.com [...]

  • http://realurl.org/twitted.php?id=5976093361 Twitted by TodePhotographe

    [...] This post was Twitted by TodePhotographe [...]

  • rodney

    What about LockCalendar. It really only offers calendar info but it does it and it does it very well.

  • rodney

    What about LockCalendar. It really only offers calendar info but it does it and it does it very well.

  • iPer

    I just updated Lockinfo, and now it only show emails from my SPAM folder? Whats up with that? I’ve tried to reinstall it, delte it, then install it again etc. But no go. I even deleted the spam emails from my email-client, but they still show up on the lockinfo screen.

    Anyone got a fix for this?

  • iPer

    I just updated Lockinfo, and now it only show emails from my SPAM folder? Whats up with that? I’ve tried to reinstall it, delte it, then install it again etc. But no go. I even deleted the spam emails from my email-client, but they still show up on the lockinfo screen.

    Anyone got a fix for this?

  • http://gumballtech.com/ brian

    Hmm… Never heard of that. May need to contact the developer. He’s usually good in giving support via email: david@ashman.com

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    Hmm… Never heard of that. May need to contact the developer. He’s usually good in giving support via email: david@ashman.com

  • dr3w

    iPer – I’m having the same problem — only seeing spam emails from my gmail account on lockinfo as of today’s update. wee!

  • dr3w

    iPer – I’m having the same problem — only seeing spam emails from my gmail account on lockinfo as of today’s update. wee!

  • zawan

    LOCKINFo..

    So what if it’s paid?? It deserves the 5 bucks… and think about the ongoing upgrades!!

    LOVE IT!!!

  • zawan

    LOCKINFo..

    So what if it’s paid?? It deserves the 5 bucks… and think about the ongoing upgrades!!

    LOVE IT!!!

  • rendawg90

    Smartscreen sucks. What a waste of 5 bucks. LockInfo is where its at.

  • rendawg90

    Smartscreen sucks. What a waste of 5 bucks. LockInfo is where its at.

  • Chinz

    Hi,

    i have tried using LockInfo and feel that it is a wonderful application to have. It provides me with all the information i require (notification for email, sms, missed calls.)

    Unfortunately, i realised that the battery seems to be drained at a faster rate. My battery seems to last 20% shorter with LockInfo enabled. Battery used to last at least for 16hrs per charge but with LockInfo enabled, it only last for 12hrs.

    I am not sure if other users are having similar experiences. If so, maybe this app can be improved to optimise the battery life.

    This is no doubt still a great app.

  • Chinz

    Hi,

    i have tried using LockInfo and feel that it is a wonderful application to have. It provides me with all the information i require (notification for email, sms, missed calls.)

    Unfortunately, i realised that the battery seems to be drained at a faster rate. My battery seems to last 20% shorter with LockInfo enabled. Battery used to last at least for 16hrs per charge but with LockInfo enabled, it only last for 12hrs.

    I am not sure if other users are having similar experiences. If so, maybe this app can be improved to optimise the battery life.

    This is no doubt still a great app.

  • http://gumballtech.com/ brian

    12-16 hours?! What are you doing? Turning on so you can see the lock screen and turning it back off every so often???

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    12-16 hours?! What are you doing? Turning on so you can see the lock screen and turning it back off every so often???

  • Chinz

    Hi Brian,

    i set my iphone to receive Push Mails for MS Exchange. I expect the battery life to last shorter than usual. But, is it a norm for the battery life to be reduced by approx 20%. (Main reason why i love LockInfo is also because it informs me of any missed emails and upcoming appts.)

    I have introduced it to a few of my colleagues and they loved it. Unfortunately, because of the reduction in battery life, we are finding it a challenge to use the phone for our whole work day (0800hrs – 0000hrs). Usually, with LockInfo enabled, my phone will reach abt 10% battery life by 2000hrs.

    To aid in optimization :
    - I receive approx 30 emails a day.
    - I seldom use the phone to surf the net or play games.
    - I did not use my phone to listen to music.

  • Chinz

    Hi Brian,

    i set my iphone to receive Push Mails for MS Exchange. I expect the battery life to last shorter than usual. But, is it a norm for the battery life to be reduced by approx 20%. (Main reason why i love LockInfo is also because it informs me of any missed emails and upcoming appts.)

    I have introduced it to a few of my colleagues and they loved it. Unfortunately, because of the reduction in battery life, we are finding it a challenge to use the phone for our whole work day (0800hrs – 0000hrs). Usually, with LockInfo enabled, my phone will reach abt 10% battery life by 2000hrs.

    To aid in optimization :
    - I receive approx 30 emails a day.
    - I seldom use the phone to surf the net or play games.
    - I did not use my phone to listen to music.

  • http://gumballtech.com/ brian

    I guess that is pretty good. I went all day yesterday (and night) not plugging it in to anything and got about 30 hours until it reached 1%.

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    I guess that is pretty good. I went all day yesterday (and night) not plugging it in to anything and got about 30 hours until it reached 1%.

  • http://www.google.com/search?q=plsjyoxb qfeqblfk

    qfeqblfk…

    qfeqblfk…

  • Lockinfo fan

    Go in the settings and check inbox only, did the trick for me!

  • Stimpy5050

    I'm thrilled to see that you all are enjoying LockInfo. LockInfo 2.0 is almost ready for release with some nice new features:

    - Email previews on the lockscreen.
    - Mark emails and SMS as read directly from the lockscreen.
    - Push notification support.
    - Improved performance and stability.
    - Improved email handling.

    Just as a note the article author – I didn't write 5 icon dock (though it's some nice work). That one belongs to Saurik. I did Reflective Dock.

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    Thanks for your reply! I fixed the post :D .

  • chalx

    I'm using Intelliscreen and I'm more than happy. its hard to set correctly but it offers the best options. really, you didn't configured it correctly.

  • http://www.oliverkiss.com/ Oliver Kiss

    LockInfo is by far the most stable, reliable, and clean app!

  • http://forum.theiphoneblog.com/iphone-jailbreak-unlock/184689-lockinfo.html#post1548868 LockInfo… – The iPhone Blog Forums

    [...] Well LockInfo ($4.99) can certainly do all that while not being too flashy or a resource hog. You can also set LockInfo as a SpringBoard page to use it while the phone isn't locked. It's close to being the "all-in-one" info pane everyone wants to see in iPhone OS 4.0. The latest update now can even do some pretty nice stuff with push notifications. SmartScreen (free lite version, $4.99 full version) looks nicer but the tradeoff is performance, so SmartScreen is virtually unusable on anything but the latest generation hardware (iPhone 3GS, 3rd-gen iPod touch). There's also Cydget and QuickWidgets. I haven't tried either one. Here's a good rundown of the different options: iPhone Lockscreen Battle [...]

  • http://reviewantiagingcream.theblogtree.com/ skin tightener

    Trackback Notification…

    Publicised on this specific web property…

  • Hansel

    I first tried Intelliscreen, which is a pain to configure and get running, so i switched to Lockinfo and am more than happy with it. If only it were free…

  • http://www.thewanderingbrit.com daclements

    Great write-up. Having just jailbroken yesterday, modding my lockscreen has been one of my top priorities. I think I'm going to have to try quickwidgets first, just because it's free, but if that doesn't meet expectations, I guess it will have to be lockinfo

  • http://www.thewanderingbrit.com daclements

    Hmmmm, actually, after looking into it, it appears that quickqidgets may not be so great after all: http://modmyi.com/forums/iphone-news/692519-qui…

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    Its been a while since its been updated. The thing about it coming with paid software isn’t too big of a deal. You don’t have to use them, they just have to be installed. You won’t get nagged about paying for them either.

  • Fred V.

    I'm using intelliscreen and I love it. Setting up the categories did take a little time but its great for privacy. The front screen I have my news and weather and the back screen when I double tap, I have all my personal information (calender, mail, sms). The average iphone user who picks up my phone wouldn't be able to access my personal information unlike some of the other lockscreens where all the information is right there infront of you when they turn on the phone.

  • http://professionalhairdryers.org.uk Nupspaway

    Howdy im fresh here. I hit upon this board I find It incredibly helpful and it’s helped me a great deal. I hope to contribute and support other users like its helped me.

    Thank You, See You Later

  • Howard

    Maybe someone can give me some advise. I'm a new iphone 4 user and made he transition from a Blackberry bold. Right now I am very unhappy about the way the iphone handles email notification. Let me explain why and maybe one of you can tell me which one of these apps can fill the void.

    First, I have 8 e-mail accounts. Yes, perhaps this is a lot, but they are all very specific, each relating to some aspect of my business, my position as an officer in Civil Air Patrol, Filmmaker, etc. In any case, on the Blackberry, each of these accounts was represented by a separate icon. What is visible on the home screen is a unified mail icon, the same as on the iphone. Click it and all the emails from all the accounts are combined. I rarely if ever used that. But now to the core of the matter.

    When an email was received by any of the accounts, the first thing that would happen is that a red LED would start blinking on the top right front of the phone. You could also make it make a sound and/or vibrate. This immediately alerted you to receipt of an email across any of the accounts or a text message. Clicking any key then woke up the screen. There the one email visible on the home screen had a red icon, indicating new mail. Clicking the “return key” to the left of the trackball then drilled you down to the rest of the phone's icons (that you chose to be visible) and among them were the EIGHT icons, each representing an individual email account. On the one of more accounts (represented by an envelop icon) that had new mail, appeared a red star on the corner.

    Again…simple…you get an email, are alerted by the blinking LED, click to wake up the home page, click on the return key, and then see precisely which email account HAS NEW MAIL.

    The iphone 4 does not do this. It is very frustrating, not just because I am new to it, but because when I unlock the phone and see I have new mail there is absolutely no indication (other than a change in a number on the mail account page, that appears next to each account name). There is no red icon. The number of emails could be red to indicate new mail…anything. I find myself just searching through the various accounts to find the new mail or going to the unified mail icon – which I prefer not to do — it does not enable me to quickly reference past mail in the same account.

    Do any of the applications discussed her preform the function I have described by previding a separate head's up on the locked page? Perhaps one of them enables you yo position an icon for each e-mail account on this page and provide an indication as to which has new mail waiting?

    I would appreciate any and all help. Because of the volume of mail I receive each day and how I use this feature, it might be a deal breaker for my transition to the iphone!

    hbmorrismarketing@gmail.com

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    I'm glad you ditched that BlackBerry :) .

    Anyway, whenever new email arrives, the Mail icon on your homescreen should have a red circle in the upper-right, indicating that there is new/unread email, as well as the number of new/unread email. Going to the initial Mail page should list all of your accounts. To the right of each account should be the number of new/unread email. It's really streamlined and easy when dealing with multiple email accounts (in my opinion). I have 5 accounts, each getting dozens of emails everyday, and find Mail in iOS 4 to be very nice and simple.

    Regarding this post – These are jailbroken applications. The iPhone 4 isn't yet jailbroken, so you can't install these applications, but these are just to give you a notification on your lockscreen of new things, such as email, SMS, etc.

  • Patrick

    I noticed the battery drainage with lockscreen too, it is still a great app and beats unlocking the phone for call and mail information.

  • http://thesecretninjaproxy.info ninja cloak

    a great post for you to read…

    [..]awesome information avialable here, definitely should go read this, it’s totally worth it[..]…

  • alex

    lockinfo is very nice looking – but it drains the battery very quickly, even though the only thing I have to auto-update is email every 15 minutes.
    Right now am using the trial, and I even did think about purchasing it, because it really is usefull, but because of the battery usage it consumes on the iphone, I will sadly, not use it further.

    If you are thinking about purchasing this item, think about these words. in 2 hours the battery level has come down from 35% to 14% – this means you will have to recharge your phone 3 – 4 times each day.

  • http://gumballtech.com brian

    Every 15 minutes? I’m pretty sure that that’s why you’re seeing a drain. I have mine set to an hour (for mail, weather, and Twitter) and I’m not seeing any decrease in battery life. I’m on an iPhone 4 running 4.0.1.

  • http://www.genericcheapviagra.com/ Bobmoreviagra

    It is very usefull information for every one…

blog comments powered by Disqus